ALL OVAC 2021-2022
| Name | Sport | Year |
| Lily Herriott | Girls Track & Field | Sr |
| Caleb Davis | Baseball | Sr |
| LaDea Waderker | Softball | Sr |
| Aiyanna Hancock | Softball | Sr |
| Olivia Congleton | Softball | Sr |
| Hayley Snyder | Wrestling | Jr |
| Brodie Tait | Wrestling | Sr |
| Abbie Smith | Girls Basketball | Sr |
| Sophie Cochran | Girls Basketball | Sr |
| Alexis Frazee | Girls Basketball | Jr |
| Bryson Angelo | Boys Cross Country | Sr |
| Grace Randall | Girls Cross Country | Sr |
| JT Rice | Football | Sr |
| Dennis Pettey | Football | Sr |
| Jason Williams | Football | Sr |
ALL OVAC 2020-2021
| Name | Sport | Year |
| Bryson Angelo | Boys Track & Field | Jr |
| Matthew Rauch | Boys Track & Field | Sr |
| Gavin Ott | Boys Track & Field | Sr |
| Brennan Perdue | Boys Track & Field | Jr |
| Millie Ryan | Girls Track & Field | Sr |
| Kurt Taylor | Baseball | Sr |
| Evan Gandee | Baseball | Sr |
| Aiyanna Hancock | Softball | Jr |
| Olivia Congleton | Softball | Jr |
| Seth Dennis | Boys Golf | Sr |
| Bryson Angelo | Boys Cross Country | Jr |
| Brennan Perdue | Boys Cross Country | Jr |
| Allison Werry | Girls Cross Country | Sr |
| Kurt Taylor | Football | Sr |
| Evan Gandee | Football | Sr |
| Josh Welch | Football | Sr |
| Peyten Kellar | Football | Sr |
| Dennis Pettey | Football | Jr |
| JT Rice | Football | Jr |
ALL OVAC 2019-2020
| Name | Sport | Year |
| Seth Dennis | Boys Golf | Jr |
| Abby Gilliand | Volleyball | Sr |
| Kurt Taylor | Football | Jr |
| Evan Gandee | Football | Jr |
| Peyten Kellar | Wrestling (Champion) | Jr |
| Cole Coleman | Wrestling | Jr |
ALL OVAC 2018- 2019
| Name | Sport | Year |
|---|---|---|
| Austin Barta | Golf | Sr |
| Trent Sayre | Boys Cross Country | Sr |
| Brennan Perdue | Boys Cross Country | Fr |
| Casey Brague | Girls Cross Country | Sr |
| Devanne Reynolds | Girls Cross Country | So |
| Diamond Decker | Volleyball (5A Player of the Year) | Sr |
| Victoria Lewis | Volleyball | Sr |
| Brandon Simoniette | Football | Jr |
| Josh Welch | Football | So |
| Drew Huffman | Baseball | Sr |
| Brett Gandee | Baseball | Jr |
| Diamond Decker | Softball | Sr |
| Olivia Shutts | Softball | Sr |
| Trent Sayre | Track and Field | Sr |
| Brennan Perdue | Track and Field | Fr |
| Isaiah Kitts | Track and Field | Sr |
| Justin Lough | Track and Field | Jr |
| Ethan Yost | Track and Field | Jr |
| Jake Herriott | Track and Field | Sr |
| Erin Bogard | Track and Field | Sr |
| Millie Ryan | Track and Field | So |
ALL OVAC 2017 - 2018
| Name | Sport | Year |
|---|---|---|
| Thomas Miller | Football | So |
| Ronnie Hill | Football (special mention) | Sr |
| Tyler Schafer | Football (special mention) | Jr |
| Nick Ward | Golf | Sr |
| Hope Murdock | Volleyball | Sr |
| Casey Brague | Girls Cross Country | Sr |
| Devanne Reynolds | Girls Cross Country | Fr |
| Trent Sayre | Boys Cross Country | Jr |
| Drew Huffman | Baseball | Jr |
| Sarah Greenlee | Softball | Sr |
| Elisabeth Williams | Softball | Sr |
| Avery Grayson | Softball | Sr |
| Landon Wigal | Track Pole Vault | Jr |
| Ethan Yost | Track 4x400 4x800 | Soph |
| Trent Sayre | Track 4x400 4x800 1600 | Jr |
| Jake Herriott | Track 4x800 | Jr |
| Preston Rowland-Demster | Track 4x800 | Soph |
| Justin Lough | Track 4x400 300 hurdles | Soph |
| Isaiah Kitts | Track 4x400 | Jr |
| Erin Bogard | Track Pole Vault | Jr |
| Millie Ryan | Track Discuss | Fr |
