ALL OHIO 2021-2022
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Alexis Frazee | Girls Soccer | Jr | 2nd Team |
| Hayley Snyder | Girls Wrestling | Jr | State Champion 110 lb |
| Kylee Tait | Girls Wrestling | So | 2nd Place 140 lb |
| Abbie Smith | Girls Basketball | Sr | 2nd Team |
| Alexis Frazee | Girls Soccer | Jr | Honorable Mention |
| Brayden Sallee | Boys Basketball | Sr | 3rd Team |
| Trent Taylor | Boys Basketball | So | Honorable Mention |
ALL OHIO 2020-2021
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Taylor Sloan | Girls Soccer | Sr | 2nd Team |
| Kurt Taylor | Football | Sr | Honorable Mention QB |
| Evan Gandee | Football | Sr | 2nd Team WR |
| Joel Chevalier | Football | Sr | 2nd Team PK |
| Josh Welch | Football | Sr | Honorable Mention LB |
| Peyten Kellar | Football | Sr | Honorable Mention DB |
| Abbie Smith | Girls Basketball | Jr | 3rd Team |
| Seth Dennis | Boys Basketball | Sr | OPSWA Special Mention |
| Brayden Sallee | Boys Basketball | Jr | OPSWA Honorable Mention |
| Hayley Snyder | Girls Wrestling | So | State Champion |
| Peyten Kellar | Wrestling | Sr | State Champion |
| Millie Ryan | Girls Track & Field | Sr | Discus (4th) - Shot Put (6th) |
| Evan Gandee | Baseball | Sr | Honorable Mention |
ALL OHIO 2019-2020
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Kurt Taylor | Football | Jr | Special Mention QB |
| Evan Gandee | Football | Jr | Special Mention WR |
| Joel Chevalier | Football | Jr | Special Mention PK |
| Abbie Smith | Girls Basketball | So | 3rd Team |
| Molly Grayson | Girls Basketball | Sr | Special Mention |
| Hayley Snyder | Girls Wrestling | Fr | State Champion |
ALL OHIO 2018-2019
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Ethan Yost | Boys Soccer | Jr | 2nd Team |
| Peyten Kellar | Wrestling | So | All Ohio |
| Isaiah Kitts | Boys Track and Field | Sr | 4X400 Relay 3rd Place |
| Justin Lough | Boys Track and Field | Jr | 4X400 Replay 3rd Place |
| Trent Sayre | Boys Track and Field | Sr | 4X400 Relay 3rd Place |
| Ethan Yost | Boys Track and Field | Jr | 4X400 Relay 3rd Place |
| Jake Herriott | Boys Track and Field | Sr | 4X800 Relay 2nd Place |
| Ethan Yost | Boys Track and Field | Jr | 4X800 Relay 2nd Place |
| Trent Sayre | Boys Track and Field | Sr | 4X800 Relay 2nd Place |
| Preston Rowland-Demster | Boys Track and Field | Jr | 4X800 Relay 2nd Place |
| Justin Lough | Boys Track and Field | Jr | 300M Hurdles 3rd Place |
| Trent Sayre | Boys Track and Field | Sr | 1600M 2nd Place |
| Ethan Yost | Boys Track and Field | Jr | 800M 3rd Place |
| Erin Bogard | Girls Track and Field | Sr | Pole Vault State Champion |
| Millie Ryan | Girls Track and Field | Sr | Discus 6th Place |
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Zed Strahler | Boys Soccer | Sr | 2nd Team |
| Matt Dugan | Boys Soccer | Sr | 2nd Team |
| Josh Huffman | Boys Basketball | Sr | Special Mention |
| Kate Liston | Girls Basketball | Sr | Special Mention |
| Peyten Kellar | Wrestling | Fr | All Ohio |
| Ethan Yost | Boys Track and Field | So | 4X800 Relay 2nd Place |
| Jake Herriott | Boys Track and Field | Jr | 4X800 Relay 2nd Place |
| Preston Rowland-Demster | Boys Track and Field | So | 4X800 Relay 2nd Place |
| Trent Sayre | Boys Track and Field | Jr | 4X800 Relay 2nd Place |
| Trent Sayre | Boys Track and Field | Jr | 4X800 Relay 2nd Place |
| Justin Lough | Boys Track and Field | So | 300M Hurdles 3rd Place |
| Ethan Yost | Boys Track and Field | So | 400M 8th Place |
| Erin Bogard | Girls Track and Field | Jr | Pole Vault 3rd Place |
ALL OHIO 2016-2017
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Jacob Davis | Baseball | Sr | 1st Team Catcher |
ALL OHIO 2015-2016
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Colton Cantley | Boys Soccer | Sr | 2nd Team |
| Brent Ash | Boys Cross Country | Sr | 19th Place |
ALL OHIO 2014-2015
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Mason Pilkey | Boys Track and Field | Sr | Discus 8th Place |
| Cole Wigal | Boys Track and Field | Sr | Pole Vault 5th Place |
| Michael Hall | Boys Basketball | Sr | 2nd Team |
| Brandon Pahl | Wrestling | Sr | 285 lb 8th Place |
| Raeli Barnes | Girls Soccer | Sr | 3rd Team |
| Aaron Mazurkiewicz | Boys Soccer | Sr | 2nd Team |
ALL OHIO 2013-2014
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Raelyn Gardner | Girls Track and Field | Sr | Pole Vault 5th Place |
| Michael Hall | Boys Basketball | Jr | Honorable Mention |
| Evan French | Boys Basketball | Sr | 1st Team |
| Brandon Pahl | Wrestling | Jr | 285 lb 4th Place |
| Raeli Barnes | Girls Soccer | Jr | 3rd Team |
| Alex Miller | Boys Soccer | Sr | 1st Team |
| Parker Blain | Boys Cross Country | Sr | 18th Place |
| Kendra Lynch | Softball | Sr | 2nd Team Short Stop |
ALL OHIO 2012-2013
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Evan French | Boys Basketball | Jr | 1st Team |
| Melissa Dickerson | Girls Soccer | Sr | 3rd Team |
| Nick Koch | Boys Soccer | Sr | 2nd Team |
ALL OHIO 2011-2012
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Emma Ryan | Girls Track and Field | Jr | Discus 7th Place |
| Evan French | Boys Basketball | So | Special Mention |
| Allie Grace Proctor | Girls Basketball | Sr | 3rd Team |
| Melissa Dickerson | Girls Soccer | Jr | 2nd Team |
| Jeremy Fivecoait | Football | Sr | 3rd Team WR |
ALL OHIO 2010-2011
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Emma Ryan | Girls Track and Field | So | Discus 3rd Place |
| Tyler Proctor | Baseball | Jr | 1st Team Infielder |
| Hannah Zimmerman | Softball | Sr | 2nd Team Catcher |
| Austin Cunningham | Boys Basketball | Sr | 3rd Team |
| Caleb Jones | Boys Soccer | Sr | 1st Team |
ALL OHIO 2009-2010
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Emma Ryan | Girls Track and Field | Fr | Discus 4th Place |
ALL OHIO 2008-2009
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Tyler Cox | Boys Track and Field | Sr | Pole Vault 3rd Place |
| Billy Koch | Boys Soccer | Sr | 1st Team |
| Alaina Mcauley | Volleyball | Sr | 3rd Team |
ALL OHIO 2007-2008
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Tyler Cox | Boys Track and Field | Jr | Pole Vault 3rd Place |
| Tyler Cantley | Boys Track and Field | Sr | 4X800 Relay State Champ |
| Nick Wilson | Boys Track and Field | Sr | 4X800 Relay State Champ |
| Justin Roush | Boys Track and Field | Sr | 4X800 Relay State Champ |
| Sam Majoy | Boys Track and Field | Sr | 4X800 Relay State Champ |
ALL OHIO 2006-2007
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Tyler Cantley | Boys Cross Country | Jr | 5th Place |
| Nick WIlson | Boys Cross Country | Jr | 8th Place |
| Nick Wilson | Boys Track and Field | Jr | 4X800 Relay 5th Place |
| Tyler Cantley | Boys Track and Field | Jr | 4X800 Relay 5th Place |
| Sam Majoy | Boys Track and Field | Jr | 4X800 Relay 5th Place |
| Wes Richards | Boys Track and Field | Sr | 4X800 Relay 5th Place |
| Tyler Cantley | Boys Track and Field | Jr | 1600 M Run 3rd Place |
| Emily Bonnette | Girls Track and Field | Sr | Long Jump 4th Place |
ALL OHIO 2005-2006
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Amber Clatterbuck | Softball | Sr | 1st Team Pitcher |
| Tyler Cantley | Boys Track and Field | So | 1600M 6th Place |
| Scott Swaney | Boys Soccer | Sr | 3rd Team |
| Nate Eksi | Boys Soccer | Sr | 3rd Team |
ALL OHIO 2004-2005
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Summer Baumgard | Girls Track and Field | Sr | High Jump 7th Place |
| Ben Majoy | Boys Track and Field | Sr | 4X800 Relay 5th Place |
| JD Harshbarger | Boys Track and Field | Jr | 4X800 Relay 5th Place |
| Jered Mitchem | Boys Track and Field | Sr | 4X800 Relay 5th Place |
| Tyler Cantley | Boys Track and Field | Fr | 4X800 Relay 5th Place |
| Jered Mitchem | Boys Track and Field | Sr | 800M 6th Place |
| Tyler Cantley | Boys Track and Field | Fr | 1600M 6th Place |
ALL OHIO 2003-2004
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Stacie Shrider | Girls Track and Field | Sr | Shot Put 3rd Place |
| Sinda Bailey | Girls Track and Field | Sr | Pole Vault 3rd Place |
| Jenna Wittekind | Girls Track and Field | Sr | Long Jump 7th Place |
| Lance Wellspring | Boys Track and Field | Jr | 4X400 Relay 8th Place |
| Josh Blackburn | Boys Track and Field | Sr | 4X400 Relay 8th Place |
| Chance Glover | Boys Track and Field | Jr | 4X400 Relay 8th Place |
| Dustin Smith | Boys Track and Field | So | 4X400 Relay 8th Place |
| Stacie Shrider | Girls Basketball | Sr | 1st Team |
| Sam Wagner | Boys Soccer | Sr | 2nd Team |
ALL OHIO 2002-2003
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Stacie Shrider | Girls Track and Field | Jr | Shot Put 5th Place |
| Sinda Bailey | Girls Track and Field | Jr | Pole Vault 3rd Place |
| Lyndsey Lemon | Softball | Sr | 1st Team Short Stop |
ALL OHIO 2001-2002
| Name | Sport | Year | Team |
| Chris Hendricks | Football | Sr | 2nd Team LB |